Match Duel #1: Blackwings vs. Lancer Frogs
0/10 points

Deck Construction: 12/20 points

• Pot of Avarice in a semi-Grave reliant deck that doesn’t fill the Grave regularly enough and in depth isn’t a good idea
• Tragoedia is not needed
• The Dark Creator is a win more card that is unnecessary
• Sangan is not needed
• Could do with more Mystical Space Typhoon/Forbidden Lance/Book of Moon
• Lacks Dark Armed Dragon
• 2 Starlight Road is too much
• Could do with some more defensive traps
• Extra needs more variety of XYZs; you never summon Dark Mist in here
• Need the Level 8 Blackwing
• Expected sided in D.D. Crows or Bottomless’

Performance: 6/20 points

G1
• T1 set too much backrow too early
• Used Kalut needlessly
• Set MST needlessly
• Tributing for Gorz wasn’t needed and cost too much resources
• Used Necro Gardna to protect Sangan when you should’ve let him be destroyed
• Should have dumped Sirocco with Arma Knight considering you had Vayu in hand
• Should have set Vayu instead of Bora

G2
• Could have opened with nothing for Gorz so you could use Bora as an SS later on
• Should have attacked with Blizzard before Synchroing in case of Gorz
• Should have used Allure before using Vayu’s effect to make sure you’d be making the most optimal play
• Used Black Whirlwind at the wrong time, effectively weakening potential Trag and making Gorz dead
• Did not get a monster off of Whirlwind


Replays:

http://www.slingfile.com/file/kZzbCdb8iw
http://www.slingfile.com/file/vZV8eP45Xo


Match Duel #2: Twilight vs. T.G. Stun
10/10

Deck Construction: 10/20 points

• Duality in a deck with Wulf and milling is bad
• Could be using Warrior Returning Alive since you have enough targets
• No need for Aurkus or Ehren with no JD
• Needs some MSTs
• Could do with Plaguespreader Zombie and Card Trooper
• Extra has too many Synchros and not enough variety of XYZs
• Siding into Blackwing Twilight isn’t an effective strategy against most decks
• Was using JD twice before the match fully got underway

Performance: 11/20 points

G1
• Used Foolish on Wulf too early
• Should have used Charge to grab Lumina and set Ryko to begin with
• Set Beckoning too early, this killed your Gorz later on and was made more dead by Avarice
• Set Ryko too early; set cards Main Phase 2 if you attack or else you’re making moves without knowing what your enemy has

G2
• Should have played Zenmaines in DEF


Replays:

http://www.slingfile.com/file/iWA813rwsQ
http://www.slingfile.com/file/j9EHQHhFS0


Different Decks: 3/3
Attitude: 2/2

Total: 54/100

You'll be staying in Slifer!

I would like it if decato would score this since he was the one who gave it to me and the reason for this is i had to make some changes to deck because i forgot that jd was banned and also i feel that Kenshi Judges the tests alot harder than anyone else. Not saying that Kenshi is bad just harder on tests.

I award fairly and justly. You just happened to have average decks and made average to below average plays. Compiling these reports takes time and it's quite naive to think that another tester would mark you when I have posted a full one. The only reason I marked you is because Decato has too much on his plate. All current testers hold confidence in one another's abilities so I doubt your request will be fulfilled.

About the Judgment Dragon incident, I was told to knock some points off of Deck Construction for that, which I did.

I asked Kenshi to do the report for me since I had like 4 reports to do and I agree with his scoring.

Thanks. I can handle the rest... DP added and locked.