Ok so I was bored and thought I would make a thread and just tell players how I personally see them in terms of Yu-Gi-OH! skills, deck building performance etc. I'm not saying I am a pro or anything coz I also have much to learn but at the same time I will call out people on misplays and mistakes when I feel there was a better play/choice to make.

So how this will works, a player just needs to post here, if they want that is, with something like ''Me'' and I'll respond with what I think of the players Yu-Gi-Oh! skills. Just a heads up, as the title says, I will be a 'Realist' and what I say may come across as very cold and brutal but you can assure I will not lie to you. Don't post here if you are over sensitive or get offended easily.

Anyways, if you have the BALLS! Then get you self evaluated by yours truly!

yolo

DarkMadzishN wrote:

yolo

You are the typical European player which YO3! was full of, you don't tend to follow the simplistic play style of the USA or their trends. You plan a good few turns ahead and read a situation fairly decent but at times you are reckless and scream YOLO. But that's not necessarily a bad thing coz a player needs to know when to push. You are the META noob of 2013.

Sure, what the hell.. I'll take that

Boattack wrote:

Sure, what the hell.. I'll take that

My dear boattack, I have only dueled u a couple of times and so my judgment maybe a little outdated or narrow, but from what I have seen, you still haven't developed the abilities that can put you with in the same class as the top players. You need to read games better and really know what the best optimal play is with the cards you have, that being said, your deck building also needs work and when it comes to deck building, you can't always be stubborn and think ''No I am right, these cards are useful'' sometimes you need to pick up from others and follow certain, not all, but certain trends. That being said, your play style and deck building maybe due to you not caring about competitive play, maybe u play for fun. As i said, i haven't dueled you enough to know about you.

META Noob of 2013? Then what am I?

Im provablt going to regret this but im curious

I shall witness your judgment about me, but probably ignore what has been said moments later. COME AT ME

exactly what I needed today lol

Salik wrote:

Anyways, if you have the BALLS! Then get you self evaluated by yours truly!

I have big balls now come evaluate them...

if ya no wat i mean

Dragoon wrote:

META Noob of 2013? Then what am I?

Dragoon your deck building has actually improved from when I 1st met you which is good, i especially noticed this when I saw your RP deck submission, which was almost identical to my original submission but you still lacked that bit of creativity to make the deck BEASTLY! I haven't dueled you in a while but from what I can remember, you still need to work on making the right choices in a game as you still make some dumb moves/ choices, you also don't know when to push to burn out your opponents resources and play too passive sometimes. I noticed this from one of your recent replays, but safe to say you are developing.

LustfulZex wrote:

Im provablt going to regret this but im curious

When I 1st met you, I thought you were a good player, but then soon after I realised you seem to be a bit clueless in certain duel situations and struggle to think on optimal ways to come back into a game. You know what the correct basic plays to make are but you are yet to develop on thinking outside the box for that ''WOW WTF CRAZY'' play that would just leave your opponent left for dead. You need to analyse all your plays more, especially when doing combos with several cards to maximise all the benefits from the resources you have.

NickV wrote:

I shall witness your judgment about me, but probably ignore what has been said moments later. COME AT ME

You have common sense and KNOW how to play the game, and you actually know how to read fairly well, tbh I don't quite know why you don't win more duels. I think maybe it's in the deck building or maybe in the ratios of card choices in your deck building that let you down, coz from what I know and have seen, when you have the resources you need, you use them all correctly.

dubina wrote:

exactly what I needed today lol

You are the definition of a textbook player, you know about cards and how to use them correctly, you know how to build correctly, but you never play the best deck lol, you always play the second best or third best deck, you don't follow the crowd. I actually enjoy dueling you coz it's always a GOOD duel. You play your cards correctly but recently you are misplaying and making stupid mistakes but I am guessing this is because you don't care for the game atm due to the META. In a skilled format you would be 1 of the top players imo. You are still a dick tho LOL.

Chaos Creator wrote:

Salik wrote:

Anyways, if you have the BALLS! Then get you self evaluated by yours truly!

I have big balls now come evaluate them...

if ya no wat i mean

You are one of the noobiest players I have met in my life, I don't know what the solution to helping you is, you don't know how to play skillfully, I mean you know how to make basic plays and do fairly decent but you read the game horribly and lack common sense. You don't know how to think ahead either. You need to pay more attention when you duel good players and pick up on some of their plays and maybe watch replays and realise why certain people make certain moves. You just need to think more.

.........LOL?

(No Offense to anybody)

lol finally a real fun thread XD

loop wrote:

lol finally a real fun thread XD

Lol Loop, you are typical arrogant ''pro'' player who thinks he is the best. That being said, you also know how to play the game, how to deck build, how to side etc. I can't fault your game logic but sometimes I think you lose focus in game and make mistakes, but that's just maybe from laziness. I can't really saying anything coz you've beat me, more times than I've beat you XD.

Me, cus i dont give a f*** about what you tink about me and who knows it could be helpful

simtem wrote:

Me, cus i dont give a f*** about what you tink about me and who knows it could be helpful

You still are at the average level, deck building has room for improvement, once you hit that level of where you understand how to deal with everything with a handful of cards, you will understand. Haven't dueled you in a while, but from what I remember, you know how to make basic plays but you're not quite at that stage where you can predict and read continuously through out a game.

Boo

Decato wrote:

Boo

(I feel so unqualified to this since in my early days on NEDA/CEA I tried to learn from him xD)

Another textbook player, cannot fault your deck building or choices in a duel, you don't seem to be in the game lately, but when you were, them days in season 1 and half way through season 2, you were on point. I haven't dueled you in soooo long! Like Dubina, in a skillful format, you would also be at the top. Nothing else to say.

Me please thanks, this should make quite the entertainment for me today hopefully.

Yubel wrote:

Me please thanks, this should make quite the entertainment for me today hopefully.

Last time i dueled you i think was in a bash few months ago, you used dragons and you made several mistakes when it came to banishing the right dragons. I don't think you have learned how to predict ahead yet, but rather just focus on that specific turn. Your plays have gotten better from since you were a Slifer, but you still have room for improvement when it comes to reading and counter playing an opponent.

mwe :3 ?